Big Y Cakes Prices in 2023

Updated: September 9, 2023


Big Y Cakes stands as a beacon of popularity in the realm of cake shops nationwide. What sets them apart is the harmonious fusion of affordability and exceptional quality in every delectable creation they offer. With an extensive array of basic styles and flavors, each cake is a testament to their unwavering commitment to taste and value. Beyond the classics, Big Y Cakes takes customization to new heights, crafting themed confections tailored for any special occasion.

While their selection may not overwhelm with sheer volume, the diversity in designs is where Big Y Cakes truly shines. Every cake is a canvas, awaiting personalization to suit the unique celebration it graces. From the exuberance of birthdays to the tender moments of baby showers, the triumphant milestones of graduations, and an array of other special gatherings, Big Y Cakes elevates the experience with their artistry.

This article serves as your guide, shedding light on the intricacies of their pricing structure and the captivating range of designs available for events that mark life’s most cherished moments. Whether it’s a whimsical celebration or an elegant soirée, Big Y Cakes ensures that every slice is an unforgettable experience.

Big Y Cakes Prices

Cake TypePrice
Big Y Round Cakes
8-inch One Layer Round Cake (Serves 10)$9.99
8-inch Two Layer Round Cake (Serves 12)$14.99
8-inch One Layer Round Character Cake (Serves 10)$14.99
8-inch Two Layer Round Character Cake (Serves 12)$19.99
Big Y Sheet Cakes
¼ Sheet Cake (Serves 24)$17.99
½ Sheet Cake (Serves 48)$27.99
Full Sheet Cake (Serves 96)$42.99
¼ Sheet Character Cake (Serves 24)$23.99
½ Sheet Character Cake (Serves 48)$32.99
Full Sheet Character Cake (Serves 96)$47.99

Company History

In July 2016, Big Y made a significant announcement regarding its strategic moves in response to the impending Ahold/Delhaize merger. The company revealed its involvement in a purchase agreement with Ahold and Delhaize Group, a deal that encompassed the acquisition of eight Hannaford Brothers sites situated in Massachusetts. This transaction was a pivotal step required to secure approval from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) for the impending merger of Ahold and Delhaize.

The newly acquired Hannaford-converted stores are strategically positioned in Kingston, Quincy, Norwell, Milford, Norwood, West Peabody, Saugus, and Easton, Massachusetts. This expansion marked a significant milestone for Big Y, increasing their store count in Massachusetts to an impressive total of 37, solidifying their presence from the picturesque Berkshires to the bustling urban landscape of Greater Boston.

Fast forward to December 2021, and Big Y’s footprint had expanded even further. The company was operating a total of 72 supermarkets, primarily concentrated in key regions such as Springfield, Worcester, Greater Boston, and Hartford, spanning across both Massachusetts and Connecticut. Notably, Big Y’s offerings extended beyond traditional supermarkets, encompassing two specialty markets: Table & Vine, a renowned liquor and wine emporium in West Springfield, and Fresh Acres Market, a pioneering concept in Springfield that seamlessly blended an open-air farmers’ market with upscale dining options.

Furthermore, Big Y ventured into the realm of fuel and convenience, opening 12 petrol stations and convenience stores under the banner “Big Y Express” between 2013 and 2021. These strategically positioned Big Y Express locations were often found adjacent to or in close proximity to full-sized Big Y supermarkets, providing customers with added convenience and access to their favorite grocery destinations.

Big Y Cakes Selection

The Big Y offers a delightful array of cakes tailored to suit various themes and occasions. From character cakes to sports-themed creations, as well as specialized designs for holidays and special events, they have it all. The options for customization are boundless, allowing you to opt for either their charming basic designs or craft a one-of-a-kind bespoke cake.

Their standard repertoire includes enchanting themes like Alice in Wonderland, dynamic sports motifs like Basketball, and a variety of transportation-themed designs such as Cars, Trucks, and Vehicles. And if that’s not enough, they’re open to exploring additional creative concepts.

Moreover, you have the liberty to further personalize your cake by selecting from an extensive range of cake shapes, frosting designs, frosting colors, icing types, and delectable cake flavors. Whether you opt for a custom creation or choose from their pre-designed selection, Big Y goes the extra mile by offering complimentary frosting messages to add a personal touch.

Birthday Cakes

Big Y boasts an impressive array of birthday cake designs suitable for both children and adults. Whether you’re celebrating a little one’s special day or an adult milestone, Big Y has the perfect cake to fit the theme. Opt for a classic sheet cake adorned with vibrant balloons or elegant flowers. Alternatively, take it a step further and order a personalized cake in a distinctive shape that truly captures the essence of the celebration. With Big Y, your birthday cake dreams are limited only by your imagination.

Baby Shower Cakes

Big Y takes pride in crafting exquisite baby shower cakes that add a touch of sweetness to this joyous occasion. Their selection includes a range of charming designs, from adorable onesies to whimsical baby booties, all skillfully created to celebrate the impending arrival of a little bundle of joy. Whether you prefer soft pastels or vibrant hues, Big Y offers a variety of color options to suit your theme. You can also customize the cake with the baby’s name or other special messages, creating a personalized touch that makes the cake truly unique. With Big Y’s attention to detail and commitment to quality, their baby shower cakes are sure to be a delightful centerpiece for this memorable celebration.

Wedding Cakes

Big Y specializes in creating exquisite wedding cakes that serve as a delectable centerpiece for your special day. Their selection includes a wide range of elegant designs, from classic tiered cakes adorned with intricate floral arrangements to modern and minimalist creations. You can choose from an array of delicious cake flavors and fillings to suit your preferences. Big Y also offers customization options, allowing you to add personalized touches like monograms, edible flowers, or intricate lace patterns.

Graduation Cakes

Big Y presents a delightful selection of simpler, ready-made cakes that effortlessly bring a festive spirit to any occasion. Specifically, they cater to the celebration of academic milestones with their custom graduation cakes. These cakes can be tailored to incorporate school colors and showcase the interests and hobbies of the graduate, ensuring a truly personalized touch. Additionally, for those inclined towards athletics, Big Y offers a selection of sports-themed cakes, sure to delight any sports enthusiast. For a closer look at their designs, a visit to their official website is highly recommended.

With Big Y, there’s no need to search any further, as they offer a diverse range of cakes suitable for a multitude of occasions. Not only are these cakes visually appealing, but they also boast a delectable taste that’s sure to leave customers thoroughly satisfied. Don’t hesitate to try one of their cakes today and share your experience with us! Your taste buds are in for a treat.

How to Order?

Ordering from Big Y is a straightforward and convenient process. Follow these steps to place your order:

  • Visit the Website: Start by visiting the official Big Y website.

  • Select Your Location: Locate and select your nearest or preferred Big Y store location. This will ensure that you’re viewing the correct products and availability for your area.

  • Browse Cake Options: Navigate to the bakery section or search for cakes specifically. Browse through the available options, including standard designs, custom cakes, and themed cakes for various occasions.

  • Choose Your Cake: Once you’ve found a cake that catches your eye, click on it to see more details. This may include options for sizes, flavors, and customization.

  • Customize (If Desired): If you opt for a customizable cake, you’ll likely have the opportunity to choose aspects like cake flavor, frosting type, design elements, and any personalized messages.

  • Add to Cart: Once you’re satisfied with your choices, click on the “Add to Cart” or similar button.

  • Review Your Order: Double-check your order in the cart to make sure it includes everything you want. You may also have the option to add other items or make adjustments at this stage.

  • Proceed to Checkout: When you’re ready to finalize your order, click on the “Checkout” or similar button.

  • Provide Contact Information: You’ll need to provide your contact information, including your name, phone number, and email address. This ensures that Big Y can get in touch with you regarding your order.

  • Select Pickup or Delivery: Choose whether you’d like to pick up the cake in-store or have it delivered (if delivery is an option).

  • Select Date and Time: If applicable, select the date and time for pickup or delivery. This ensures that your cake will be ready when you need it.

  • Review and Confirm: Take a final look at your order to make sure all details are correct. If everything looks good, confirm your order.

  • Payment: Provide your payment information to complete the order. This may include credit/debit card details or other accepted payment methods.

  • Confirmation: Once your order is successfully placed, you should receive a confirmation email or notification with the details of your order, including pickup or delivery information.

What sets Big Y Cakes apart in terms of pricing?

Big Y Cakes is renowned for offering high-quality cakes at remarkably affordable prices. This unique combination of quality and affordability sets them apart in the industry.

What is the range of cake prices at Big Y Cakes?

The prices at Big Y Cakes vary depending on factors such as size, complexity of design, and special requests. However, all their cakes are competitively priced to ensure accessibility for a wide range of customers.

Do they offer budget-friendly options for customers with specific pricing constraints?

Yes, Big Y Cakes understands the importance of catering to various budget ranges. They have a selection of cakes designed specifically for those looking for more economical options without compromising on taste or quality.

Can I request a custom-designed cake within a specific budget?

Absolutely! Big Y Cakes is known for its flexibility in accommodating special requests. They work closely with customers to create custom cakes that align with their budgetary preferences while ensuring a delightful experience.

Are there any additional costs for themed or specialty cakes?

Themed or specialty cakes may have additional costs depending on the complexity of the design and any special ingredients or materials required. However, Big Y Cakes provides transparent pricing and communicates any extra charges upfront.

Do they offer discounts for bulk orders or frequent customers?

Big Y Cakes values their loyal customers and may offer discounts for bulk orders or repeat business. It’s recommended to inquire about any ongoing promotions or loyalty programs when placing an order.

What is the process for obtaining a price quote for a specific cake design?

To get a price quote for a specific cake design, customers can contact Big Y Cakes directly through their website, phone, or in-person visit. Providing details such as size, design preferences, and any special requirements will help in generating an accurate quote.

Is there a pricing difference for various cake sizes and flavors?

Yes, the price of a cake may vary based on factors like size, flavor, and intricacy of design. Big Y Cakes offers a diverse range of sizes and flavors to cater to individual preferences and budget considerations.


Big Y Cakes emerges as a standout in the world of cake shops, captivating customers with their remarkable blend of affordability and exceptional quality. Their diverse selection of basic styles and flavors ensures that there’s something for everyone, while their expertise in crafting themed cakes adds a personalized touch to any special occasion.

While the quantity of cakes may not be vast, the range of designs is expansive, showcasing their dedication to creativity and customization. From birthdays to baby showers, graduations, and beyond, Big Y Cakes transforms each celebration into a memorable experience.

The pricing structure at Big Y Cakes reflects their commitment to accessibility without compromising on taste or craftsmanship. Whether you’re on a specific budget or seeking a lavish creation, their willingness to work closely with customers ensures a seamless and satisfying experience.

Jeff Campbell

Jeff Campbell

I'm Jeff Campbell, a seasoned leader with an extensive background at Whole Foods Market spanning over two decades. Throughout my career, I had the privilege of working in nine different stores across four states, not to mention my contributions to numerous other stores in various capacities. Recognized as a Global All-Star and a recipient of the prestigious Gold Pen Award, I also had the honor of winning the highly coveted Top-10 Store title three times on a company-wide level. Additionally, I achieved the distinction of Best New Store across the entire company.

Please Write Your Comments