Cakes by Karen Prices, How to Order, & More in 2023

Updated: August 23, 2023


Where culinary artistry meets celebrations. Crafters of bespoke confectionery wonders, they specialize in curating exceptional cakes that grace birthdays, weddings, and all cherished moments in between. Meticulously sourcing the finest ingredients, their creations tantalize taste buds while mesmerizing eyes.

Distinguished by their commitment to uniqueness, each custom cake is a testament to individuality, a masterpiece born from collaborative imagination. This boutique bakery extends an expansive array of baking services, where every creation is an ode to perfection. The essence of quality resonates in every bite, as they meticulously handcraft each delicacy to order, using only the most superior components.

Within their delectable repertoire lie an array of delights – muffins, scones, Danish cookies, pies, quiches, cupcakes, cobblers, and the pièce de résistance, cakes that evoke dreams. Whether envisioning a creation or presenting a captured moment, Cakes by Karen breathes life into sugar and flour. Not confined by dietary preferences, they embrace the challenge of sugar-free, gluten-free, and vegan renditions.

What makes Cakes by Karen unique?

Cakes by Karen distinguishes itself through a blend of creativity, quality, and personalized service. What sets them apart is their unwavering commitment to creating unique and memorable experiences for each client:

  1. Bespoke Artistry: Cakes by Karen doesn’t just make cakes; they craft edible works of art. Their unique designs are a reflection of their clients’ visions, meticulously brought to life through skillful craftsmanship.

  2. Tailored Creations: Unlike mass-produced cakes, every creation at Cakes by Karen is tailor-made. They take the time to understand each client’s preferences, ensuring that every cake tells a unique story and resonates with the occasion it celebrates.

  3. Premium Ingredients: The emphasis on using only the highest-quality ingredients elevates their creations to new heights. This commitment to quality not only enhances the taste but also ensures that the final product meets the highest culinary standards.

  4. Versatility: Beyond cakes, they offer an extensive range of baked goods. This versatility allows clients to find the perfect treat for any occasion, whether it’s muffins for a breakfast gathering or a grand wedding cake.

  5. Inclusivity: Cakes by Karen caters to various dietary needs. Their willingness to create sugar-free, gluten-free, and vegan options ensures that everyone can indulge in their delightful creations.

  6. Collaborative Approach: Their process involves collaboration with clients. They take client ideas or images and turn them into edible reality, making each creation a joint venture between the bakers and the clients.

  7. Attention to Detail: From intricate decorations to impeccable finishes, Cakes by Karen pays attention to the smallest details. This dedication to perfection results in cakes that not only look stunning but also leave a lasting impression.

  8. Wedding Expertise: Their expertise in crafting wedding cakes makes them a sought-after choice for couples. They capture the essence of love stories through their wedding cake designs, making them an integral part of the celebration.

  9. Memorable Experiences: Cakes by Karen doesn’t merely sell cakes; they create unforgettable experiences. Their creations become centerpieces of joy, wonder, and celebration, leaving a lasting memory for clients and their guests.

Cake Prices at Cakes By Karen

Kindly note that personalized cake orders are facilitated through scheduled appointments. Our tiered cake pricing is determined on a per-serving basis. Commencing with round cakes at a base rate of $2.50 per serving, our diverse range of uniquely shaped cakes starts at $2.75 per serving. For those seeking the exquisite touch of fondant, our offerings start at $3.50 per serving.

Delivery and setup charges are subject to variation based on geographical location. Our tiered cakes boast double layers, with delectable fillings or luscious icing nestled in between. For the addition of sumptuous fillings, a nominal extra charge of $0.25 per serving is applicable.

Cake TypePriceExtra Filling
6” Round – Serves: 4 – 5$20.98$2 more
8” Round – Serves: 10 – 12$26.98$2 more
10” Round – Serves: 15 – 20$39.98$2 more
1/4 Sheet – Serves 15 – 18$27.98$2 more
1/2 Sheet – Serves 25 – 35$44.98$2 more
Full Sheet – Serves 75 – 95$71.98$6 more
Custom Cakesvariesvaries

Cakes by Karen Specializes in Wedding Cakes

Indulge in a delightful array of flavors and fillings, showcasing our most sought-after selections. Should your heart yearn for a flavor beyond these, rest assured, your desires are our command!

Cake Flavors:

Among our captivating options lie Chocolate, Yellow, White, Lemon, Orange, Banana, Marble Fudge, Pound Cake, Strawberry, French Vanilla, Red Velvet, Almond, Mocha Chocolate*, Flourless Chocolate*, Atomic*, Carrot Cake*, and Cheese Cake*.

Exquisite Fillings:

Enhancing every slice, our repertoire of fillings encompasses Strawberry Pie, velvety Chocolate Mousse, Bavarian Cream, zesty Pineapple, tangy Lemon, succulent Cherry, vibrant Raspberry, rich Fudge, delectable Creme Brulee, ethereal Raspberry Mousse, luscious Strawberry Mousse, luxurious White Chocolate Mousse, Dark Ganache Truffle, Nutty Hazelnut (with or without nuts), indulgent Chocolate Hazelnut (with or without nuts), Fresh Strawberry*, and Fresh Banana*.

Enchanting Fillings Continued:

Embark on a journey through taste with our Butter Cream, the innovative Special Blend (resembling whipped cream but enduring at room temperature like butter cream, free from spoiling), velvety Chocolate Butter Cream, alluring Chocolate Special Blend, the artistic Fondant, and the enchanting Chocolate Fondant.

Inclusive Delights:

For weddings exceeding 100 guests, the crowning glory – the top tier (first-anniversary cake) of all bridal cakes – is our heartfelt gift to you. Revel in an expansive array of cake toppings, and when a tiered masterpiece graces your celebration, the topper becomes yours at a delightful 20% discount.

Deposits and Returns:

For cakes accompanied by stands, a deposit is requisitioned, promptly refunded upon the stand’s safe return. To ensure a full refund, kindly return the stand and/or pillars within one week post-wedding, having bestowed upon them a gentle cleansing. Your trust and satisfaction drive us to elevate each moment into a memory worth savoring.

What’s Cakes by Karen and What Does it Offer?


Nestled within Highland, Indiana, Cakes by Karen stands as a cherished local gem, a testament to dedicated craftsmanship. Servicing not only Highland but the encompassing regions, this establishment is a cornerstone of its community.

Infused with the essence of family, Karen herself presides over this quaint yet impactful endeavor. A tribute to intimacy and authenticity, Cakes by Karen embodies the spirit of a family-owned enterprise devoted to delivering Indiana’s finest confections.


True to its name, Cakes by Karen excels in the art of crafting confectionery marvels for every occasion. From weddings to birthdays, showers to those irreplaceable moments, custom cakes are their hallmark.

However, their expertise doesn’t stop at cakes alone. Cakes by Karen extends an array of delectable baked goods and pastries, ranging from muffins, cupcakes, scones, and Danishes, to cookies, quiches, pies, cobblers, and dainty French desserts. Even the celebration of holidays finds expression in their creations, such as the delightful paczki for Paczki Day.

Amid their well-curated portfolio, Cakes by Karen beckons your creativity. They embrace custom designs, whether born from your imagination or sketched on paper. Notably, the pursuit of perfection necessitates an in-person consultation for bespoke cakes, ensuring impeccable quality and design precision.


Elevating personalization to an art form, Cakes by Karen grants life to your visions. Envision your cherished image transformed into an edible masterpiece – they will effortlessly transpose your picture onto cakes and cookies, a feast for both the eyes and taste buds.

Cakes by Karen invites you to experience the magic of melding artistry with indulgence, where each bite carries a legacy of dedication and heart.

Flavors Galore

Cakes by Karen takes pride in offering a diverse spectrum of both classic and popular flavors for their cakes and fillings. While their showcased options are certainly enticing, your imagination knows no bounds. Should your taste buds yearn for a flavor beyond their presentation, rest assured that Cakes by Karen will bring your vision to life.

Below, you’ll find a selection of Cakes by Karen’s most beloved flavors.


  • Chocolate
  • Yellow
  • White
  • Marble Fudge
  • Lemon
  • Orange
  • Banana
  • Pound Cake
  • Strawberry
  • Red Velvet
  • French Vanilla
  • Almond

For those with a penchant for extraordinary flavors, Cakes by Karen extends a premium assortment available at an additional charge:

  • Flourless Chocolate
  • Mocha Chocolate
  • Carrot Cake
  • Atomic
  • Cheese Cake


  • Bavarian Cream
  • Chocolate Mousse
  • Strawberry Pie
  • Cherry
  • Lemon
  • Pineapple
  • Fudge
  • Raspberry
  • Crème Brulee
  • Raspberry Mousse
  • Strawberry Mousse
  • White Chocolate Mousse
  • Dark Ganache Truffle
  • Hazelnut
  • Chocolate Hazelnut
  • Butter Cream
  • Chocolate Butter Cream
  • Special Blend (reminiscent of whipped cream)
  • Chocolate Special Blend

For those seeking an extra layer of indulgence, certain filling varieties are available at an added cost:

  • Fresh Strawberry
  • Fresh Banana
  • Fondant
  • Chocolate Fondant

Cakes by Karen invites you to embark on a flavor journey that is uniquely yours. With every bite, they strive to transform your taste experience into an exquisite memory.

How to Order a Cake

Cakes by Karen simplifies the cake ordering process by offering an array of convenient“>order forms on their website. These forms cater to various preferences, ensuring a seamless experience. Apart from the general cake order forms, they extend a collection of seasonal order forms, spotlighting their finest offerings for each season.

However, should your vision involve a bespoke creation, a touch of personal interaction becomes essential. Crafting custom cakes demands an in-person consultation, fostering clear communication between you and the proficient Cakes by Karen team. This collaborative approach guarantees that the cake you bring home is an exquisite embodiment of your imagination.

For inquiries and engagement with the Cakes by Karen team, you’re welcome to reach out by dialing 219-838-2310. Alternatively, you can establish contact via email at [email protected]. Embracing both tradition and innovation, Cakes by Karen strives to make your cake journey a delightful and memorable one.

Public Perception of Cakes by Karen

The perception of Cakes by Karen among the public is a blend of opinions. On“>TripAdvisor, the business maintains a respectable three-star rating.

Praised by patrons, Cakes by Karen garners acclaim for the excellence of their cakes. Customers marvel at the seamless fusion of aesthetics and flavors, with the cakes being lauded for their visual allure and delightful taste. Karen’s frosting artistry garners special admiration, rivaling the finesse typically attributed to fondant decorations. While acknowledging the cakes’ premium pricing, the consensus remains that the splurge is justified by the superb quality.

Nevertheless, there exists a contingent with differing viewpoints on Karen and her creations. Some voices have raised concerns about cakes falling short of their descriptions or images depicted prior to pickup. A handful have also expressed dissatisfaction with customer service, pointing out instances of brusqueness.

Interestingly, amidst these diverse viewpoints, a common thread emerges: unanimous satisfaction with the taste of the cakes. Regardless of varying experiences, there are no grievances concerning the delectable flavors.

For those considering a cake from Cakes by Karen in the near future, the recommendation is simple: articulate your design preferences with utmost clarity. By doing so, you can contribute to ensuring an outcome that satisfies all parties involved.

Operation Hours

  • Tuesday – 4:30 am to 1:00 pm
  • Wednesday – 4:30 am to 3 pm
  • Thursday – 4:30 am to 3 pm
  • Friday – 4:30 am to 3 pm
  • Saturday – 4:30 am to 3 pm
  • Sunday – Closed

Cakes by Karen presents a diverse array of personalized flavors and fillings. Indulge in private tastings, available at an associated fee, or explore their selection of pre-designed cakes. Notably, delivery and setup services can be arranged, commencing at a base fee of $50. Their hallmark lies in tailoring most orders to match individual preferences, thereby resulting in distinct pricing for different cake designs. Feel free to reach out today and engage in a conversation about transforming your envisioned cake into a tangible masterpiece.

Are you already familiar with the enchantment of Cakes by Karen? Share your thoughts and experiences using the comment form below! Your feedback is valued.

Do they offer a variety of baked goods besides cakes?

Yes, Cakes by Karen offers an extensive selection of baked delights, including muffins, scones, Danish cookies, pies, quiches, cupcakes, cobblers, and other little French desserts, showcasing their versatile expertise.

Can I request a custom cake design?

Absolutely! Cakes by Karen specializes in custom cake designs. They collaborate closely with clients, transforming ideas or images into stunning edible art that reflects personal preferences and occasions.

Do they accommodate dietary restrictions?

Yes, Cakes by Karen is known for their inclusivity. They offer options such as sugar-free, gluten-free, and vegan cakes, ensuring that everyone can indulge in their delectable creations.

How can I place an order?

Placing an order is easy. You can visit their website or contact them directly via phone or email to discuss your preferences, design ideas, and event details.

What is their lead time for orders?

The lead time for orders can vary based on the complexity of the design and the size of the order. It’s advisable to get in touch with Cakes by Karen as early as possible to secure your spot in their schedule.

Do they offer wedding cake services?

Yes, Cakes by Karen specializes in crafting stunning wedding cakes that capture the essence of the couple’s love story. They work closely with brides and grooms to create a centerpiece that’s both visually striking and delicious.

Where is Cakes by Karen located?

You can find Cakes by Karen’s location on their website. They may have a physical bakery where you can visit to discuss your orders or pick up your creations.


Cakes by Karen stands as a beacon of creativity and craftsmanship in the world of confectionery. With an unwavering commitment to excellence, they have redefined the art of baking by infusing every creation with a touch of magic. The uniqueness that emanates from Cakes by Karen lies not only in the delectable flavors and stunning designs but also in the way they transform dreams into reality.

Their dedication to tailoring each masterpiece to the client’s vision showcases a rare level of personalized service. From elaborate wedding cakes that capture the essence of love stories to the tiniest muffin that brightens a morning, every creation is infused with passion and precision. By combining the finest ingredients with an artistic eye, Cakes by Karen transcends the boundaries of traditional baking.

The versatility that they bring to the table is exceptional, catering to a wide range of tastes and dietary preferences. Embracing challenges such as crafting sugar-free, gluten-free, and vegan options, they ensure that joy knows no bounds and that everyone can partake in the delight of their creations.

Jeff Campbell

Jeff Campbell

I'm Jeff Campbell, a seasoned leader with an extensive background at Whole Foods Market spanning over two decades. Throughout my career, I had the privilege of working in nine different stores across four states, not to mention my contributions to numerous other stores in various capacities. Recognized as a Global All-Star and a recipient of the prestigious Gold Pen Award, I also had the honor of winning the highly coveted Top-10 Store title three times on a company-wide level. Additionally, I achieved the distinction of Best New Store across the entire company.

Please Write Your Comments