Everything You Need to Know About Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes

Updated: October 16, 2023


Are you someone who envisions a world filled with delectable cakes, delightful macarons, tempting cupcakes, and scrumptious cookie sandwiches, stretching out as far as the eye can see?

If so, you’re bound to fall head over heels for Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes – an enchanting boutique that not only boasts an array of adorable and mouthwatering confections but also provides an array of charming party supplies.

History of Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes

Kelsey’s passion for baking and decorating has been a lifelong affair. In 2012, she transformed this love into a full-fledged career by establishing Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes, a delightful party boutique brimming with an array of delectable cakes and charming treats, perfect for impromptu indulgences, intimate gatherings, or grand celebrations.

Her formal training took her to the esteemed Peggy Porschen Cake Academy in London, where she honed her skills under the guidance of Peggy Porschen herself, a renowned European cake designer. After earning her diploma, Kelsey extended her stay with Peggy to collaborate on crafting exquisite sugar flowers for her upcoming cake collection.

At the academy, Kelsey delved into a comprehensive curriculum encompassing sugar flower design, baking proficiency, tiered cake construction, wedding cake intricacies, and precise piping techniques. Beyond her studies with Peggy Porschen, she sought further expertise, learning the art of sugar flowers from Maggie Austin, mastering fondant work under Erica O’Brien’s guidance, and perfecting Lambeth method piping with Wendy Kromer.

Kelsey’s exceptional talents have earned her recognition in esteemed publications like Reader’s Digest and appearances on the Katie Couric Show, marking just a few of her many achievements.

To witness the exquisite creations of Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes, peruse their Instagram feed or explore their portfolio. Prepare to be tantalized—each masterpiece is so visually captivating that it might just leave your taste buds tingling with anticipation.

Read also: McDonald’s Ice Cream Prices & Flavors

Yelp reviewers are effusive in their praise for Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes, particularly lauding the exquisite macarons and birthday cakes.

Here’s a tempting rundown of their 12 signature cake flavors:

  • White Almond: Three layers of airy white almond cake adorned with luscious vanilla buttercream.
  • Chocolate Fudge: Nostalgic layers of fudgy chocolate, complemented with a choice of vanilla buttercream or chocolate fudge frosting.
  • Chocolate Salted Caramel: Decadent chocolate cake layered with homemade caramel buttercream, sprinkled with sea salt, and finished with a swirl of vanilla buttercream.
  • Maple Cinnamon: A harmonious fusion of cinnamon-infused maple cake crowned with a velvety vanilla maple cream cheese frosting.
  • Homemade Lemon Curd: Classic white cake enveloping zesty homemade lemon curd, available with either vanilla buttercream for a sweet contrast or lemon buttercream for an extra tart kick.
  • White Raspberry: A wedding cake variation with white almond layers embracing a filling of fresh raspberry buttercream, all swathed in vanilla buttercream.
  • Peanut Butter Bliss: Indulgent chocolate fudge cake cradling a creamy peanut butter center, crowned with a choice of chocolate, vanilla, or peanut butter buttercream.
  • Neapolitan Rose: Layers of chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, chocolate fudge, and strawberry preserves harmonize under a medley of chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry buttercream.
  • Vanilla Blackberry: White cake housing a delectable blackberry buttercream filling.
  • German Chocolate: Chocolate cake layered with a rich German chocolate filling, toasted pecans, and coconut.
  • Red Velvet: A crimson-hued milk chocolate cake enfolding a sumptuous cream cheese frosting, all enrobed in velvety vanilla buttercream.
  • Snicker’s: Chocolate cake encasing layers of peanut butter buttercream, caramel buttercream, and chopped nuts, crowned with a luscious coat of chocolate buttercream and adorned with a Snicker’s candy bar.

The delightful offerings at Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes can be categorized into various delectable flavor groups. For cupcakes, you have the classics such as triple chocolate, French toast, and Funfetti. There’s also a tempting selection of candy bar and cookie-inspired flavors like snickerdoodle, chocolate chip cookie dough, and birthday Oreo.

For those with a penchant for fruity delights, options like coconut lemon, chocolate-covered banana, and strawberry lemonade await. Indulge your palate further with dessert-inspired choices including s’mores, banana split, and Boston cream pie. If you’re in the mood for breakfast-themed treats, don’t miss out on blueberry pancake, cinnamon roll, or jelly donut flavors. Additionally, seasonal offerings like pumpkin spice, carrot cake, and gingerbread come with specified availability dates for your planning pleasure.

As for the macarons, they’re equally enticing with flavor categories ranging from classics like vanilla bean, pistachio, and sea salt fudge to chocolate variations such as triple chocolate, mocha, and hot cocoa. Candy-inspired options like Reese’s, Butterfinger, and Starburst provide a sweet twist, while the ice cream lineup boasts tantalizing selections like orange creamsicle, root beer float, and mint chocolate chip. Those seeking a fruity kick will relish choices like raspberry, blackberry, and cherry limeade. Lastly, for a touch of whimsy, explore fun flavors like Fruity Pebbles, Nutella, or buttered popcorn.

KEC Cake Collections and Party Trays

Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes offers a diverse array of cake collections to cater to various preferences and occasions. These include the Buttercream Cake Collection, Party Cake Collection, Cupcake Collection, Custom Cakes, and Party Trays.

The Buttercream Cake Collection boasts a range of styles, including the classic rose cake, large rose cake, petal cake, ruffle cake, retro dot cake, wave cake, blossom cake, and hand-painted floral cakes.

Meanwhile, the Party Cake Collection, Cupcake Collection, and Party Tray selections are ideal for gatherings where you require treats for multiple guests. While customization options for design and flavors are limited to streamline the selection process, you have the option to include a personalized message for the guest of honor.

In terms of size and flavor options, you can choose from six different cake sizes, with tantalizing flavors such as macaron sprinkle, Oreo fudge, vanilla caramel fudge, cinnamon roll, Neapolitan rose, s’mores, ice cream sundae, Snicker’s, white raspberry preserves, strawberry lemonade, Reese’s, and cookie dough.

For those seeking a truly unique creation, the Custom Cakes option is available. Contact Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes directly for personalized details, allowing for a more precise price quote and a discussion about the specific cake you envision for your special occasion. Known for their sophistication, elegance, and versatility, these custom cakes can be tailored in terms of intricacy, colors, details, artwork, and more, with the price reflecting the level of complexity involved in bringing your vision to life.

KEC Wedding Cake Collection

Planning a wedding? Look no further than Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes’ dedicated wedding cake collection. You have the option to personalize these three-tiered wedding cakes to suit your unique vision. Alternatively, opt for a fully custom order to craft the perfect one, two, or three-tiered masterpiece for your special day.

Curious about the taste? We completely understand (plus, wedding cake tasting is a delightful experience!). KEC provides four different tasting boxes for soon-to-be-wed couples to savor. For just $10, you’ll have the chance to sample three cake flavors and three fillings. If you’re eager to try even more, you can add another box for $8. Simply get in touch via call or email, or place your order for a tasting box. Please note that KEC requires a minimum of 24 to 48 hours to prepare your order for pickup.

Here are the most sought-after tasting boxes:

  • The Classic 1 Box includes vanilla, white almond, and chocolate cakes paired with vanilla buttercream, raspberry buttercream, and chocolate fudge.
  • The Classic 2 Box offers vanilla, white almond, and chocolate cakes complemented by vanilla buttercream, raspberry buttercream, and salted caramel buttercream.
  • The White Cake Lovers Box features vanilla, white almond, and maple cinnamon cakes, each adorned with vanilla buttercream, lemon curd, and maple cream cheese frosting.
  • The Chocolate Cake Lovers Box presents white almond and two chocolate cakes, all accompanied by vanilla buttercream, salted caramel buttercream, and peanut butter buttercream.

You have the freedom to select any three flavors and fillings from their extensive lists to create a personalized tasting experience.

Pricing of Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes​

For a standard buttercream cake at Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes, you can expect the following price ranges:

  • Single Tier (Serving 6 to 40 people): $35 to $98 (available in 5 size options)
  • Two Tier (Serving 16 to 60 people): $86 to $200 (offering 4 different sizes)
  • Three Tier (Serving 45 to 100 people): $225 to $350 (with 4 size variations)

Additionally, they offer:

  • Smash Cake: $18
  • Cupcakes: $2.50 to $4 each
  • Macarons: $2 to $3 each

For a comprehensive breakdown of their pricing, you can refer to their full pricing sheet on their website.

Are You Craving a Kelsey Elizabeth Cake Now?

Indulge your sweet tooth at either of Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes’ two charming locations:

  • 720 Avon Belden Rd., Avon Lake, OH 44012
  • 20033 Detroit Rd., Rocky River, OH 44116

Operating hours are Tuesday through Friday from 10am to 6pm, and Saturday from 10am to 3pm. The shop is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

Feel free to visit the shop and explore the delightful array of sweets or conveniently place an order online via email.

If you’re picking up your order at the Avon Lake location, please email [email protected]. For orders to be collected at the Rocky River location, reach out to [email protected].

In your email, remember to specify the desired size or number of servings, flavor preference, buttercream pattern (if applicable), chosen color scheme, and the date you require the order by.

To ensure availability, kindly place your email order at least 2 to 3 weeks in advance. Once KEC reaches their maximum order capacity for a given week, they may be unable to accept additional orders (although they will do their best to accommodate last-minute requests, there are no guarantees).

Please note that due to the high volume of emails received, the expected response time is between 2 to 5 days. For immediate assistance, don’t hesitate to call them at 440-653-5883 (Avon Lake) or 216-767-5633 (Rocky River).

P.S. If you’re a cake enthusiast living in Ohio, Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes is currently hiring.

What makes Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes stand out from other bakeries?

At Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes, we pride ourselves on creating not only delicious but also visually stunning confections. Each treat is a work of art, meticulously crafted to bring joy to your taste buds and eyes alike. Our commitment to quality ingredients and attention to detail sets us apart, making every visit a memorable experience.

What types of cakes and confections does Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes offer?

Our menu features an extensive array of delectable options, including custom-designed cakes, mouthwatering macarons, tempting cupcakes, and irresistible cookie sandwiches. Whether you have a specific flavor in mind or want to explore our seasonal specials, there’s something to satisfy every palate.

Can I request a custom-designed cake for a special occasion?

We specialize in creating bespoke cakes tailored to your unique preferences and the theme of your event. Our talented team will work closely with you to bring your vision to life, ensuring a one-of-a-kind centerpiece for your celebration.

Does Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes offer gluten-free or allergen-friendly options?

Yes, we understand the importance of accommodating dietary restrictions. We offer a selection of gluten-free and allergen-friendly options, allowing everyone to indulge in our delectable creations without worry.

What additional services does Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes provide?

In addition to our delectable confections, we also offer a range of cute party supplies to enhance your celebration. From charming decorations to stylish cake toppers, we’ve got everything you need to make your event truly special.

How can I place an order with Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes?

Ordering from us is a breeze! You can visit our shop in person to discuss your preferences with our friendly staff, or conveniently place an order online through our user-friendly website. We strive to make the process as seamless as possible.

Does Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes offer delivery services?

Yes, we offer delivery services to select areas. Simply provide us with the necessary details, and we’ll ensure your delectable treats arrive at your doorstep right on time.

How can I stay updated on Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes’ latest offerings and promotions?

To stay in the loop about our newest creations and special promotions, be sure to follow us on our social media channels and subscribe to our newsletter. You’ll be the first to know about all the sweet surprises we have in store!


Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes is more than just a bakery; it’s an experience crafted with love and dedication. With a commitment to quality, creativity, and customer satisfaction, we take pride in offering a wide array of delectable treats that are sure to delight your senses.

Whether you’re seeking a custom-designed cake for a special occasion or simply want to indulge in our mouthwatering macarons and cupcakes, we’re here to make your moments sweeter. Our dedication to accommodating dietary needs ensures that everyone can savor our creations.

Jeff Campbell

Jeff Campbell

I'm Jeff Campbell, a seasoned leader with an extensive background at Whole Foods Market spanning over two decades. Throughout my career, I had the privilege of working in nine different stores across four states, not to mention my contributions to numerous other stores in various capacities. Recognized as a Global All-Star and a recipient of the prestigious Gold Pen Award, I also had the honor of winning the highly coveted Top-10 Store title three times on a company-wide level. Additionally, I achieved the distinction of Best New Store across the entire company.

Please Write Your Comments