Safeway Cakes Prices, Models & How to Order in 2023

Updated: June 17, 2023


Safeway, a renowned supermarket chain, presents a delectable range of cakes to suit every occasion. Their prices are incredibly reasonable, starting at just $9.99 for an 8″ round cake, and extending up to $117.99 for an extravagant 3-tier wedding cake. The convenience of ordering is unmatched, as Safeway provides the option to order both premade and custom cakes either online or in-store, utilizing their comprehensive cake catalog. Additionally, Safeway’s bakery section boasts an enticing assortment of cupcakes, cookies, and donuts, perfect for satisfying any sweet tooth.

Choosing Safeway cakes for your special occasion brings with it a rich history and a commitment to excellence. Safeway’s humble beginnings trace back to a small market purchased by a man, who passed it on to his son. Fueled by determination, Safeway set out to establish the highest industry standards, implementing “sell by” dates on perishable items. This practice ensures that customers receive only the freshest and highest quality products. Today, Safeway remains steadfast in upholding the values it was founded upon. With over 2,200 stores spread across the United States, Safeway consistently delivers exceptional products at fair prices, making their bakery an ideal choice for ordering your next special occasion cake.

Furthermore, Safeway’s bakery caters to a wide range of events, including graduation ceremonies, birthdays, weddings, and more. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their extensive operating hours, with the bakery open from 7 am to 7 pm, seven days a week. This ensures that customers are accommodated at any time of the day, making it incredibly convenient to plan and order for your desired event.

What is the price range of Safeway cakes?

The price range of Safeway cakes can vary depending on factors such as size, design complexity, and any additional customization requested. Safeway offers cakes at different price points to accommodate various budgets and occasions.

For smaller cakes, such as round cakes or sheet cakes that serve a limited number of people, the prices can start as low as $10 to $15. These basic cakes are often pre-decorated with simple designs and may have limited customization options.

As the size and complexity of the cake increase, so does the price. Larger sheet cakes or tiered cakes designed for bigger gatherings or special events can range from $20 to $100 or more. Customization requests, such as specific designs, intricate decorations, or personalized messages, may also incur additional charges.

It’s important to note that the prices mentioned are approximate and can vary based on location and specific Safeway bakery. It’s recommended to contact your nearest Safeway bakery directly or visit their website for the most accurate and up-to-date pricing information.

Sheet Cakes
Full Sheet$55.99
1/2 Sheet$45.99
1/4 Sheet$29.99
1/8 Sheet$19.99
Round Cakes
8″ Single Layer$9.99
8″ Double Layer$19.99
Cupcake Cakes
12 Count$13.30
24 Count$18.99
Wedding Cakes
2 Tier$91.30
3 Tier$117.99

Safeway Cake Models

At Safeway, the possibilities for cake customization are endless. Whether you’re in a rush and need a pre-decorated cake or you want Safeway’s skilled cake decorators to craft a unique design just for you, they have got you covered. With a wide array of options ranging from frosting and chocolate to fresh fruit and candy, Safeway’s cake decorations are sure to satisfy your cravings and elevate any occasion.

If you’re looking to add an extra touch of charm to your cake, Safeway offers plastic toppers that create themed designs, making your cake even more visually appealing. These toppers can tie in perfectly with the theme of your event, whether it’s a child’s birthday party, a wedding reception, a baby shower, a school graduation, or any other special celebration. Safeway’s cake decorators are skilled in bringing your vision to life, ensuring that your cake becomes the centerpiece of the occasion.

The versatility of Safeway’s cake selection is remarkable. They offer a variety of sizes and shapes, including round cakes, square sheet cakes, rectangular sheet cakes, and pull-apart cakes that separate into individual cupcakes. This extensive range allows you to choose the perfect size and shape for your event, whether you’re hosting an intimate gathering or a large party.

Safeway Baby Shower Cake

Safeway takes pride in offering a delightful array of cake options to enhance your traditional baby shower. With their expertise in cake decoration, they can create a classic cake in a variety of colors such as white, pink, blue, yellow, green, or purple, adding a touch of charm and elegance to your special event.

When it comes to baby shower cake designs, Safeway understands the importance of simplicity and sweetness. They offer delicate floral borders that add a gentle and feminine touch to the cake. Additionally, they can incorporate icing designs such as toy alphabet blocks, further emphasizing the joyous theme of welcoming a new addition to the family.

To make the baby shower cake even more enchanting, Safeway provides a selection of plastic toppers. These toppers, featuring small babies, booties, or carriages, add a whimsical touch to the cake, creating a visually appealing centerpiece that captures the essence of celebrating the arrival of a precious little one.

If you wish to personalize the cake, Safeway offers the option to have a congratulatory or welcoming message written on top. This thoughtful gesture allows you to express your warm wishes to the baby and parents, adding a personal touch to the cake that will be cherished and remembered.

Safeway Birthday Cake

When time is of the essence and you find yourself in need of a birthday cake, Safeway has convenient options to meet your requirements. You can opt for one of their pre-decorated cakes, which can be personalized with a complimentary birthday message. Alternatively, Safeway offers the flexibility to choose a custom design for your cake.

For customized cakes at Safeway, the price may vary slightly depending on the level of additional decorations. If you desire extra adornments such as plastic toppers or toys, there may be a nominal increase in the cake’s price. However, this additional cost is well worth it for the beautiful enhancements they provide.

Safeway understands the excitement of children’s birthdays and offers licensed character designs, including beloved favorites like Sesame Street. These characters can be incorporated into the cake, adding a delightful touch of familiarity and joy. Moreover, for a fun twist, Safeway also offers cupcake cakes, which appear as a single cake from the top but can be easily separated into individual cupcakes. These unique creations are perfect for birthday parties and add an element of surprise and convenience.

In the event that a Safeway Bakery is not available in your vicinity, fret not! You can swiftly make your way to the nearest Walmart Supermarket, where you are likely to find a suitable cake to meet your needs. Walmart Supermarkets typically offer a range of cake options, allowing you to find a delicious treat for your celebration.

Whether you choose Safeway or explore other options like Walmart Supermarket, you can rest assured that you will find a cake that suits your requirements. These convenient solutions ensure that you can celebrate birthdays in style, even when time is limited.

Safeway Wedding Cake

Safeway bakeries go above and beyond by offering customization options for wedding cakes, ensuring that couples can find the perfect centerpiece for their special day. They provide affordable choices, including basic two-tiered and three-tiered cakes that are both elegant and budget-friendly. These designs typically feature white icing with delicate piping in either white or the wedding colors, creating a timeless and classic look. Even with their lower price range, Safeway maintains the quality and standard of their cakes, ensuring a delightful experience for the couple and their guests.

For those seeking more extravagant options, Safeway also offers elaborate wedding cakes that can be customized in various shapes and sizes. These cakes are adorned with intricate designs, fresh flowers, and even fresh fruit, adding a touch of opulence to the celebration. The pricing for these lavish cakes varies depending on the level of complexity and size, with the average cost for a Safeway wedding cake feeding 100 guests being around $250. It’s important to note that the availability of wedding cakes is limited to select Safeway locations, and it is recommended to place an order at least a month or so in advance to ensure ample preparation time.

Safeway understands the significance of a wedding cake in creating a memorable and beautiful event. By offering both affordable and elaborate options, they cater to the diverse preferences and budgets of couples, ensuring that their wedding cake becomes a cherished part of their special day. With Safeway’s attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction, couples can trust that their wedding cake will be a stunning centerpiece that delights both the eye and the palate.

Cake TypePrice
Safeway Round Cakes
8 inch One Layer Round Cake$8.79
8 inch Two Layer Round Cake$16.49
Safeway Sheet Cakes
⅛ Sheet Cake$19.99
¼ Sheet Cake$21.99
½ Sheet Cake$45.99
Full Sheet Cake$55.99
Safeway Cupcake Cakes
12 Cupcake Cake$12.99
24 Cupcake Cake$19.99
Safeway Wedding Cakes
Two-Tiered Wedding Cake$89.99
Three Tiered Wedding Cake$119.99
Special Wedding Designs$160-$1,000

Safeway Bakery Products

To complement your delightful Safeway cakes, the Safeway bakery offers a tantalizing selection of baked goods that will satisfy every craving at your big party or special event. Their bakery menu boasts freshly baked bread and bagels that are sure to please.

Indulge in the mouth-watering options of Safeway’s bakery, which includes delectable Artisan baguettes, French bread, and Italian focaccias. These bread options are not only delicious but also low in fat, making them a wholesome choice. What’s more, they are made without any added sugar, allowing you to savor the natural flavors of the bread.

For those with dietary restrictions, Safeway understands the importance of catering to various needs. Some products in the Safeway bakery catalog can be ordered in gluten-free variants. To inquire about specific details and availability, it is recommended to contact your nearest Safeway store for further information.

The Safeway Bakery doesn’t stop at bread and bagels. They also produce an array of freshly made donuts that are sure to tempt your taste buds. These delightful treats come with decadent icings and premium fillings that take them to the next level of deliciousness. From the classic Apple Fritter to the irresistible Donut Croissant, the flavorful Persian Donuts, the indulgent Black Forest donuts, and the rich Double Chocolate donuts, Safeway offers a diverse range of options to satisfy any sweet tooth.

Safeway Graduation Cake

Safeway offers a delightful selection of readymade cakes that are perfect for celebrating and congratulating new graduates. These cakes often come with celebratory designs that capture the spirit of achievement. If you’re looking to add a personal touch, Safeway’s cake decorator can write the graduate’s name in icing right on the cake while you wait. However, if you prefer a more customized option, Safeway is more than happy to create sheet cakes or round cakes that cater to your specific requests.

When it comes to graduation cakes, there are numerous ideas to consider. Safeway understands the importance of personalization and offers options such as icing in the graduate’s school colors or frosting designs that reflect their athletic or academic interests. For instance, students who have been involved in sports may appreciate Safeway’s specially shaped round cakes that resemble a soccer ball or basketball. These unique designs add an extra element of excitement to the celebration.

No matter which design you choose, Safeway ensures that your graduation cake is made in the graduate’s favorite cake flavor. Whether it’s chocolate, vanilla, red velvet, or any other delectable option available, Safeway is committed to creating a cake that not only looks impressive but also satisfies everyone’s taste buds.

Choose Your Favorite Cake

Once you’ve made your decision on which Safeway cake is perfect for your gathering, placing an order is a breeze. Don’t worry, ordering from the Safeway cakes menu is incredibly easy and convenient. Simply give a call to your nearest Safeway location, and the friendly bakery staff will be there to assist you every step of the way. They will guide you through the ordering process, ensuring that your cake selection and any customization requests are handled with care.

To make the most of your order, it’s advisable to place it in advance. This way, you can take advantage of any ongoing sales, specials, or limited edition designs that Safeway may have available. Additionally, visiting Safeway’s website can provide you with more information and options to explore. You might also want to read reviews about Safeway cakes on our website to gather insights from others who have experienced their delicious creations.

Safeway cakes truly stand out for their exceptional quality and flavors. From the amazing taste of their cake layers to the creamy fillings, every bite is a delight. Safeway is committed to using natural ingredients whenever possible, ensuring a wholesome and enjoyable experience. Moreover, Safeway’s pricing system is fair and reasonable, making their cakes accessible to a wide range of customers.

We encourage you to share your personal experience with Safeway Bakery! Feel free to leave your feedback and thoughts in the comment section. Your input will not only help others make informed decisions but also provide valuable feedback to Safeway and their dedicated bakery team.

Frequently Asked Question

What cake models are available at Safeway?

Safeway provides a range of cake models to suit different occasions. They offer pre-decorated cakes with celebratory designs, as well as customizable options for special events. Safeway has round cakes, sheet cakes in different sizes, pull-apart cakes that separate into individual cupcakes, and even tiered cakes for weddings.

Can Safeway create custom cakes?

Yes, Safeway has the ability to create custom cakes to meet your specific requests. Whether you want a personalized design, specific frosting colors, or decorations that reflect a particular theme, Safeway’s bakery staff will work with you to bring your vision to life. Contact your nearest Safeway location or visit their bakery department for more information on custom cake orders.

Are there options for dietary restrictions?

Safeway understands the importance of catering to customers with dietary restrictions. Some Safeway bakeries offer gluten-free variants of certain products, including cakes. To inquire about specific dietary options, it’s recommended to contact your local Safeway bakery directly.

How can I place an order for a Safeway cake?

To place an order for a Safeway cake, you have a few options. You can call your nearest Safeway location and speak to the bakery staff, who will guide you through the ordering process. It’s also possible to visit Safeway’s website, where you may find online ordering options. Placing your order in advance is recommended, especially for special events, to ensure availability and allow for any customization requests.

Can I take advantage of sales, specials, or limited edition designs?

Yes, by placing your Safeway cake order in advance, you may have the opportunity to take advantage of sales, specials, or limited edition designs. Keep an eye out for promotions advertised by Safeway, both in-store and online, to make the most of your cake order.

Are there reviews of Safeway cakes available?

To read reviews and gather insights about Safeway cakes, you can visit reputable websites that provide customer feedback and ratings for various products and services. Additionally, you may find helpful reviews on Safeway’s own website or social media platforms.

How far in advance should I order a Safeway cake?

For special events or customized cakes, it’s recommended to place your Safeway cake order at least a few days in advance. However, for weddings or larger gatherings, it’s best to order your cake a month or more ahead of time to ensure ample preparation and availability.


Safeway offers a wide variety of cakes that cater to different occasions and preferences. From pre-decorated options to customizable designs, Safeway ensures that there is something for everyone. Their cakes are not only visually appealing but also delicious, with a range of flavors and fillings to choose from.

When it comes to pricing, Safeway maintains a fair and reasonable system, making their cakes accessible to customers with different budgets. By placing your order in advance, you can also take advantage of sales, specials, or limited edition designs, adding even more value to your purchase.

Ordering Safeway cakes is a simple and convenient process. You can contact your nearest Safeway location and rely on their helpful bakery staff to guide you through the ordering process. Alternatively, you can visit their website for more information and explore the available options.

Jeff Campbell

Jeff Campbell

I'm Jeff Campbell, a seasoned leader with an extensive background at Whole Foods Market spanning over two decades. Throughout my career, I had the privilege of working in nine different stores across four states, not to mention my contributions to numerous other stores in various capacities. Recognized as a Global All-Star and a recipient of the prestigious Gold Pen Award, I also had the honor of winning the highly coveted Top-10 Store title three times on a company-wide level. Additionally, I achieved the distinction of Best New Store across the entire company.

Please Write Your Comments